Health insurance is complicated... who knew?
In the bass guitar world technology has been pushing the limits with lighter weight, smaller cabinets, massive power, and more low end extension. My 6 pound head can run rings around the 65 pound heads of my youth and my 34 pound cab puts out more low end than the refrigerator sized (and weight) cabs of that same time period. Still, common wisdom is that you cannot have cheap, light, loud, and low all in one package. The laws of physics still apply along with basic economics.
In order to fix our medical care system, we must first acknowledge that the rules of math apply. It is not possible to have everyone covered with good comprehensive coverage at lower prices that are affordable to everyone without government funding and government interference. Lower priced plans with reduced coverage are only helpful until they are not. Cutting payment to physicians or other providers can only go so far before the math no longer works. A for profit entity has a bottom line commitment to the bottom line... and something eventually has to give in order for the company to make its profits. All that adds up to one inescapable conclusion.: before the ACA, the system was broken. Too many people were not insured. Too many people went bankrupt because of medical bills. Too many died because of lack of care. Treatment plans were often chosen by bean counters rather than because of efficacy. The training of physicians is expensive and favors some specialties over others regardless of actual social needs. The nature of healthcare makes it impossible for it to respond to market pressures in the same way that other industries do.
The ACA attempted to fix some of the presenting problems without addressing underlying issues. It succeeded in that small way and would have been more successful had the Republican Party not worked so hard to obstruct it. (We hear how the CBO's numbers were so off... but that ignores the fact that their numbers were based on the plan actually being adopted while 29 states refused the Medicare expansion part of the program). Because the ACA sought to work within the then, current system of for profit private insurance companies, etc., it could never deliver the product it promised of affordable, comprehensive coverage for all.
To get the product that a civilized country deserves requires a complete overhaul from top to bottom including training of physicians, funding of medical research, decisions regarding what care is provided (and not provided), how funding is allocated and what fee structures look like. It will take years to accomplish... possibly decades... but if we do not begin the process, we will see our broken system continue to deteriorate and all but the very rich will suffer.
Showing posts with label Obamacare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Obamacare. Show all posts
Thursday, April 06, 2017
Thursday, November 10, 2016
Election Results 2016 - let's get personal #1
OK... one of the issues we hear about most regarding the Obama years is the ACA and more than once I heard people say that "Hillary will double down on Obamacare." Trump has said that on day 1 he will repeal the ACA. I'm not sure how that is possible but... From what I can see the closest that the GOP has come to a proposed alternative is Paul Ryans 37 pages of talking points (it lists goals but doesn't really say how we get to any of them... and as the ACA has shown, the proof really is in the implimentation) or Trump's promise of something better with no details and as far as anyone from the outside can see, no work having been done on what would be a tremendously complex issue. Of course, the option of just repealing the ACA without replacing it with any legislative alternative is a real possibility... with all of the attendant chaos that would bring.
This one is very personal for me. I have an hereditary condition called heterozygous familial hyperlipidemia. What that means is that my liver doesn't fully function with regards to processing cholesterol and I end up with crazy high numbers of the bad kind (when I was first tested, my overall cholesterol was 613). That results in severe artery disease. Most of the men in my biological family died of heart attacks in their thirties (my father at 31). That means that on the private market I am simply uninsurable.
When it was discovered that I have this condition, my arteries were in very bad shape to the point that surgical intervention would do no good. I had not had a heart attack though. The medications (expensive) work very well for me and my cholesterol has been under control for nearly 30 years. I still have not had a heart attack and some of the arterial damage has healed itself.
Under the old system, health insurance differed dramatically from one state to another. In New York, I got excellent insurance at a reasonable price through the local council of churches which acted as a group. In California, I had to get it either through the denomination or as private insurance. Private was not available to me. Period. The broker literally laughed when he saw the medical history portion of my application. So we got it through the denomination which, because everyone who could get insurance cheaper had moved to another source, became a group of older individuals with more medical issues. I got insurance... but the year prior to the ACA, it cost nearly $4000 a month for my spouse and I. Yes. That is the correct number of zeros. When the ACA was implemented, that program disappeared because nobody was able for it to continue. Even under the ACA, our insurance started at $2000 a month... but that still was a savings of over $24000 a year.
Long story short... if the ACA is repealed without a replacement that provides insurance to people like me at a reasonable cost, I will likely die. I'm not trying to be dramatic here... only stating a reasonable understanding of what will happen.
Before the ACA, 45,000 died each year from the results of lack of insurance. 20 million people who had been uninsured got health insurance under the ACA. That number dropped significantly. If the ACA is repealed without a suitable replacement, we'll be looking at those numbers again... and I will likely be one of them.
This one is very personal for me. I have an hereditary condition called heterozygous familial hyperlipidemia. What that means is that my liver doesn't fully function with regards to processing cholesterol and I end up with crazy high numbers of the bad kind (when I was first tested, my overall cholesterol was 613). That results in severe artery disease. Most of the men in my biological family died of heart attacks in their thirties (my father at 31). That means that on the private market I am simply uninsurable.
When it was discovered that I have this condition, my arteries were in very bad shape to the point that surgical intervention would do no good. I had not had a heart attack though. The medications (expensive) work very well for me and my cholesterol has been under control for nearly 30 years. I still have not had a heart attack and some of the arterial damage has healed itself.
Under the old system, health insurance differed dramatically from one state to another. In New York, I got excellent insurance at a reasonable price through the local council of churches which acted as a group. In California, I had to get it either through the denomination or as private insurance. Private was not available to me. Period. The broker literally laughed when he saw the medical history portion of my application. So we got it through the denomination which, because everyone who could get insurance cheaper had moved to another source, became a group of older individuals with more medical issues. I got insurance... but the year prior to the ACA, it cost nearly $4000 a month for my spouse and I. Yes. That is the correct number of zeros. When the ACA was implemented, that program disappeared because nobody was able for it to continue. Even under the ACA, our insurance started at $2000 a month... but that still was a savings of over $24000 a year.
Long story short... if the ACA is repealed without a replacement that provides insurance to people like me at a reasonable cost, I will likely die. I'm not trying to be dramatic here... only stating a reasonable understanding of what will happen.
Before the ACA, 45,000 died each year from the results of lack of insurance. 20 million people who had been uninsured got health insurance under the ACA. That number dropped significantly. If the ACA is repealed without a suitable replacement, we'll be looking at those numbers again... and I will likely be one of them.
Labels:
2016 election,
ACA,
Donald Trump,
health care reform,
health insurance,
Obamacare
Tuesday, November 05, 2013
winners and losers in the ACA
No doubt you have heard reports of folk who have lost health insurance or had it increase in price because of the Affordable Care Act. I know that in some of those instances, the reporting has been less than 100% accurate. In some cases, such as with Trader Joe's, the employer discontinued their employee insurance because they calculated that their employees could get coverage through the exchanges for less than their portion of the coverage they were getting at work. Dropping them actually got them equivalent insurance for less money. In other instances, people with woefully inadequate insurance found themselves having to pay more but also receiving significantly better coverage. All that said, I know there are folk who have seen increases in the cost of their insurance and I've heard some reports for which I have no data to question, that the reason is Obamacare. And finally there are those young adults who "don't need" health insurance until of course, they do. For them, any cost is an increase.
My experience has been different. As I said in an earlier post, moving to the exchange will save significantly money for my employer. I had no idea how much. To recap, my insurance is ridiculously high for a number of reasons. Clergy are a high risk group to begin with. They tend not to take good care of themselves so heart disease, stroke, and diabetes are rampant. Clergy also tend to be older which just increases the risk pool. Finally, the health insurance we get through our denomination is an even higher risk pool as it tends to include only those who cannot get insurance elsewhere. Until the ACA, I was part of that group. I also happen to live in an area where healthcare and insurance are very expensive. We received word that for next year, our denominational healthcare plan would increase by 11.5% and the increase has nothing to do with the ACA. Additionally, the co-pays all increase as does the out of pocket limit and fewer medications are covered. Add the fact that I move into another age category and insurance for my spouse and I would cost $4251 a month. Simply, that is beyond what the church could possibly afford and minus housing allowance, is more than my salary. Looking at the exchange, it seems that a platinum plan in our area at our age would be under $1900 a month for a savings of about $2,350 a month or over a 55% savings. It is still a lot of money but the church can afford to keep me covered.
My son-in-law, daughter, and grandson will experience an even larger savings. My son has been without health insurance for 3 years because as a single male he was not eligible for any government help and could not begin to afford coverage on the open market. He will have insurance beginning January 1 and I will breathe much easier every time he plays basketball or flag football.
I guess there are losers in all of this. I still agree that the overall shape of the ACA is not the best we could have done. Given the current situation and the political climate in which we live, I am more thankful than I could say for the ACA.
My experience has been different. As I said in an earlier post, moving to the exchange will save significantly money for my employer. I had no idea how much. To recap, my insurance is ridiculously high for a number of reasons. Clergy are a high risk group to begin with. They tend not to take good care of themselves so heart disease, stroke, and diabetes are rampant. Clergy also tend to be older which just increases the risk pool. Finally, the health insurance we get through our denomination is an even higher risk pool as it tends to include only those who cannot get insurance elsewhere. Until the ACA, I was part of that group. I also happen to live in an area where healthcare and insurance are very expensive. We received word that for next year, our denominational healthcare plan would increase by 11.5% and the increase has nothing to do with the ACA. Additionally, the co-pays all increase as does the out of pocket limit and fewer medications are covered. Add the fact that I move into another age category and insurance for my spouse and I would cost $4251 a month. Simply, that is beyond what the church could possibly afford and minus housing allowance, is more than my salary. Looking at the exchange, it seems that a platinum plan in our area at our age would be under $1900 a month for a savings of about $2,350 a month or over a 55% savings. It is still a lot of money but the church can afford to keep me covered.
My son-in-law, daughter, and grandson will experience an even larger savings. My son has been without health insurance for 3 years because as a single male he was not eligible for any government help and could not begin to afford coverage on the open market. He will have insurance beginning January 1 and I will breathe much easier every time he plays basketball or flag football.
I guess there are losers in all of this. I still agree that the overall shape of the ACA is not the best we could have done. Given the current situation and the political climate in which we live, I am more thankful than I could say for the ACA.
Wednesday, October 30, 2013
Alternatives to Obamacare
I had an epiphany yesterday. Republicans in the House have voted to repeal the ACA 46 times and not once have they offered an alternative. The reason that they have not offered a reasonable alternative to Obamacare is because Obamacare was their idea. Yep. Back in 1974, the Nixon administration proposed an insurance program where all employers would provide insurance for all of their workers or face a fine. The poor would be added to an expanded Medicare and small businesses and low income folk would receive a government subsidy to help cover their insurance costs. It failed because Democrats wanted a public system rather than one based on private insurers. In 1989 the Heritage Foundation proposed a law with an individual mandate requiring everyone to purchase insurance and that feature began showing up in Republican proposals for healthcare reform up until Newt Gingrich made it a centerpiece of his agenda when he was Speaker. All of this on the federal level. Then, of course, Romney established a very similar plan in Massachusetts on the state level. Obamacare is a Republican program. A Democratic program would have centered on a public option with a single payer. The ACA is not socialized medicine, it is a program based on the private sector.
There are other options to the ACA. I prefer a single payer, public program. I think that is the only way to address the myriads of problems in our healthcare delivery system. There was no way the Republicans would have voted for truly socialized healthcare and there were enough Dems who would have sided with them that it was an idea that was dead in the water regardless of whether or not it might have been the best idea. It never even made it to the table for discussion.
I have heard two other options mentioned by some.
Leave the system alone. That is fine if you are someone who has good insurance from your employer without a large employee contribution or never experience any illnesses or accidents that cause injuries. It leaves out the folk who have no insurance or are under-insured. It causes many people to forgo treatment until it is too late and sends others to the most expensive healthcare option of all, the emergency room. It leaves those out who have pre-existing conditions which preclude them from purchasing insurance (and there is no way to stop insurance companies from excluding pre-existing conditions without an individual mandate). And regardless of what folk say, healthcare does not work like any other "free market" industry so in this option there is no way to slow the runaway price increases we've all experienced. Leaving it alone is not an option that I can see as making any sense at all.
I've recently seen multiple folk advocating another option which I find sickening (excuse the pun). They are arguing that we do away with insurance completely. Healthcare would become like any other commodity on the market with individuals bargaining with physicians and hospitals when needed, health care going only to those who can afford it, and the "free" market running its course. In their minds, those who are healthy would not have to subsidize those who are not and those who are not in this scenario are always caricatured as irresponsible folk whose poor choices are causing their problems. While there are many who do not need regular doctor visits or medications and think they can go without insurance, one accident or unexpected illness changes everything in a heartbeat. Those folk argue that a free market would bring down costs, but never imagine the ridiculousness of sitting in the emergency room with a broken bone sticking through their flesh while arguing with the doctor about the costs or leaving to go 55 miles to another hospital that treats heart attacks more inexpensively. I presume they would argue that anyone arriving at the hospital must pay in advance or not receive treatment. Without that stricture, who would pay for those who receive treatment and never pay? Most of all, this kind of idea completely excludes any sense of community and the greater good for the entire community. I can't help but think of politicians in New York and Colorado who argued against government disaster funds until their communities were struck by Sandy and terrible floods and they saw the light that we really are all in this together. The only folk for whom this option works are the very, very, very few who never get sick or injured or the extremely wealthy.
Are there other options that I've missed? Realistic ones that preserve a sense of community? I agree the ACA is not the best option. I would even agree that it does not represent any sense of a compromise. In spite of the fact that it was passed by the Dems, it is a completely Republican idea that Democrats supported, expecting that Republicans would own the baby they birthed. They did not. And they offered no reasonable alternatives... because their proposal was already on the table.
There are other options to the ACA. I prefer a single payer, public program. I think that is the only way to address the myriads of problems in our healthcare delivery system. There was no way the Republicans would have voted for truly socialized healthcare and there were enough Dems who would have sided with them that it was an idea that was dead in the water regardless of whether or not it might have been the best idea. It never even made it to the table for discussion.
I have heard two other options mentioned by some.
Leave the system alone. That is fine if you are someone who has good insurance from your employer without a large employee contribution or never experience any illnesses or accidents that cause injuries. It leaves out the folk who have no insurance or are under-insured. It causes many people to forgo treatment until it is too late and sends others to the most expensive healthcare option of all, the emergency room. It leaves those out who have pre-existing conditions which preclude them from purchasing insurance (and there is no way to stop insurance companies from excluding pre-existing conditions without an individual mandate). And regardless of what folk say, healthcare does not work like any other "free market" industry so in this option there is no way to slow the runaway price increases we've all experienced. Leaving it alone is not an option that I can see as making any sense at all.
I've recently seen multiple folk advocating another option which I find sickening (excuse the pun). They are arguing that we do away with insurance completely. Healthcare would become like any other commodity on the market with individuals bargaining with physicians and hospitals when needed, health care going only to those who can afford it, and the "free" market running its course. In their minds, those who are healthy would not have to subsidize those who are not and those who are not in this scenario are always caricatured as irresponsible folk whose poor choices are causing their problems. While there are many who do not need regular doctor visits or medications and think they can go without insurance, one accident or unexpected illness changes everything in a heartbeat. Those folk argue that a free market would bring down costs, but never imagine the ridiculousness of sitting in the emergency room with a broken bone sticking through their flesh while arguing with the doctor about the costs or leaving to go 55 miles to another hospital that treats heart attacks more inexpensively. I presume they would argue that anyone arriving at the hospital must pay in advance or not receive treatment. Without that stricture, who would pay for those who receive treatment and never pay? Most of all, this kind of idea completely excludes any sense of community and the greater good for the entire community. I can't help but think of politicians in New York and Colorado who argued against government disaster funds until their communities were struck by Sandy and terrible floods and they saw the light that we really are all in this together. The only folk for whom this option works are the very, very, very few who never get sick or injured or the extremely wealthy.
Are there other options that I've missed? Realistic ones that preserve a sense of community? I agree the ACA is not the best option. I would even agree that it does not represent any sense of a compromise. In spite of the fact that it was passed by the Dems, it is a completely Republican idea that Democrats supported, expecting that Republicans would own the baby they birthed. They did not. And they offered no reasonable alternatives... because their proposal was already on the table.
Tuesday, October 15, 2013
What the Republicans Are Doing
It has been interesting watching the media cover the ongoing political mess. Fox News has refused to call it a government "shut down," preferring instead a government "slimdown." As has been noted by some, words are important and the one who controls the language, controls the debate. On October 10 at a press conference, press secretary Carney used the word "ransom" which was rejected by the press corp as being too provocative. The Republicans have repeatedly slammed the president for "refusing to negotiate" while the president has refused to allow the economy to be held "hostage." All the while, the media has implied more or less equal blame for the mess we're facing.
At this point, it is important to clarify what has actually happened. A law was passed (the ACA). That law was judged constitutional by a very conservative SCOTUS. The electorate re-elected the president, running on the basis of that law and even a majority of voters in House races voted Democratic, all endorsing the law. Republicans, largely because of gerrymandered districts held the House majority. Some 41 times, the tried to repeal the ACA, failing every single time. It should be noted that laws get repealed and modified all of the time... through the legislative process or via the courts. Neither worked for the Republicans so they decided to do an end run, holding first the budget hostage and then the full faith and credit of the United States. Make no mistake, when the Republicans in the House were unable to repeal Obamacare via the normal means, they decided to threaten severe damage to the economy of the country and indeed the world. Give them what they want, what they could not get by normal means, or they would destroy everything.
Perhaps "ransom" is too provocative... but terrorism is an accurate description. Here's one definition I found for that word... other definitions were all similar. "The use or threatened use of force or violence by a person or an organized group against people or property with the intention of intimidating or coercing societies or governments, often for ideological or political reasons."
At this point, it is important to clarify what has actually happened. A law was passed (the ACA). That law was judged constitutional by a very conservative SCOTUS. The electorate re-elected the president, running on the basis of that law and even a majority of voters in House races voted Democratic, all endorsing the law. Republicans, largely because of gerrymandered districts held the House majority. Some 41 times, the tried to repeal the ACA, failing every single time. It should be noted that laws get repealed and modified all of the time... through the legislative process or via the courts. Neither worked for the Republicans so they decided to do an end run, holding first the budget hostage and then the full faith and credit of the United States. Make no mistake, when the Republicans in the House were unable to repeal Obamacare via the normal means, they decided to threaten severe damage to the economy of the country and indeed the world. Give them what they want, what they could not get by normal means, or they would destroy everything.
Perhaps "ransom" is too provocative... but terrorism is an accurate description. Here's one definition I found for that word... other definitions were all similar. "The use or threatened use of force or violence by a person or an organized group against people or property with the intention of intimidating or coercing societies or governments, often for ideological or political reasons."
Labels:
ACA,
government shut-down,
Obamacare,
Republican Party,
Tea Party
Tuesday, July 30, 2013
Health Insurance redux
more on the saga of health insurance for our daughter, son-in-law, and grandson on the way...
One month before Christian lost his job, his employer switched health insurance providers. That is always a pain as you have to find out whether your providers are still covered and if not, find new ones... but that was more complicated for them. Neither insurance covered the birth center and midwives they were using for the pregnancy and birth. They had negotiated coverage with the first insurance company - Anthem Blue Cross. After all, midwives and birth centers are way cheaper than doctors and hospitals. It made fiscal sense for them but it was a hassle for Christian and Alexis. They were in process of trying to negotiate the coverage with the second provider when Christian was fired.
Fast forward a few weeks... Every time you do a web search on COBRA, an ad pops up for Anthem Blue Cross as a COBRA alternative. So Christian contacted them... and they told him they would not insure his family as pregnancy is a pre-existing condition. It didn't matter that they had been insured all along and until a month ago, their insurance was with Anthem Blue Cross... they are not eligible for insurance from them. Luckily, they do still have the option of COBRA. As I understand it, that continues with the provider they had when Christian lost his job so they begin negotiations again.
As I said in my previous post, the Affordable Care Act cannot kick in soon enough.
One month before Christian lost his job, his employer switched health insurance providers. That is always a pain as you have to find out whether your providers are still covered and if not, find new ones... but that was more complicated for them. Neither insurance covered the birth center and midwives they were using for the pregnancy and birth. They had negotiated coverage with the first insurance company - Anthem Blue Cross. After all, midwives and birth centers are way cheaper than doctors and hospitals. It made fiscal sense for them but it was a hassle for Christian and Alexis. They were in process of trying to negotiate the coverage with the second provider when Christian was fired.
Fast forward a few weeks... Every time you do a web search on COBRA, an ad pops up for Anthem Blue Cross as a COBRA alternative. So Christian contacted them... and they told him they would not insure his family as pregnancy is a pre-existing condition. It didn't matter that they had been insured all along and until a month ago, their insurance was with Anthem Blue Cross... they are not eligible for insurance from them. Luckily, they do still have the option of COBRA. As I understand it, that continues with the provider they had when Christian lost his job so they begin negotiations again.
As I said in my previous post, the Affordable Care Act cannot kick in soon enough.
Thursday, July 05, 2012
The Problem with the Insurance Argument
After the Supreme Court ruling, the question of health insurance has come back to the front with Democrats celebrating and Republicans vowing to repeal. Democrats should not be celebrating and while the Republicans might be able to repeal the Affordable Care Act but they have no solution worth real discussion.
First off, the free market does not and can not work with regards to health care. The consumer has no power to influence the market at all. You can't shop for the lowest cost when you've just had a heart attack. Add that there is often only one hospital nearby and the physician on duty is the physician on duty. Most of us also have no control over what, if any, insurance is available to us and even less over what is covered by that policy. Employers may shop for the lowest price on insurance but it is very seldom that they do so while comparing two identical products and the dissimilarities may not be obvious until the product is used and the patient discovers that a specific lab or physician is not covered by their insurance. And the coverage is constantly changing so a physician covered one year may not be the next year. Which services and providers are covered by a given policy rarely if ever have anything to do with quality of care. Market forces simply do not work when it comes to health care so if we rely on them to control costs or quality, we will only see failure.
Second, there are some things that should not be sold for profit. Health care is one. In a for profit business, the business always has a primary responsibility to make money for the stock holders. There is a legal responsibility to do that regardless of whether they are producing widgets, automobiles, or providing health insurance. The first responsibility is not to the client, it is to the stock holder. Obviously, in the free market, a better product is more likely to produce higher profits for the stock holder, but the primary job of any for profit company is not to produce widgets, automobiles, or sell health insurance... it is to make money for stock holders. For health insurance companies, that means denying coverage. If they can deny a procedure, they have made more money. It is no surprise then that for profit insurance companies have employees whose job is to find ways to deny coverage to the patients and they get bonuses when they do so. At least a panel of government agents making decisions around coverage would have the well being of the larger population as their primary concern.
The bottom line is that the current system, even under Obamacare, cannot solve the problems we face and will remain the most expensive health care delivery system in the world while at the same time being far down the list in terms of almost all of the significant metrics for outcomes. The good news is that there are models around the world that actually work. All we need do is swallow our pride and embrace a model that delivers health care to all of our citizens at a more reasonable price.
First off, the free market does not and can not work with regards to health care. The consumer has no power to influence the market at all. You can't shop for the lowest cost when you've just had a heart attack. Add that there is often only one hospital nearby and the physician on duty is the physician on duty. Most of us also have no control over what, if any, insurance is available to us and even less over what is covered by that policy. Employers may shop for the lowest price on insurance but it is very seldom that they do so while comparing two identical products and the dissimilarities may not be obvious until the product is used and the patient discovers that a specific lab or physician is not covered by their insurance. And the coverage is constantly changing so a physician covered one year may not be the next year. Which services and providers are covered by a given policy rarely if ever have anything to do with quality of care. Market forces simply do not work when it comes to health care so if we rely on them to control costs or quality, we will only see failure.
Second, there are some things that should not be sold for profit. Health care is one. In a for profit business, the business always has a primary responsibility to make money for the stock holders. There is a legal responsibility to do that regardless of whether they are producing widgets, automobiles, or providing health insurance. The first responsibility is not to the client, it is to the stock holder. Obviously, in the free market, a better product is more likely to produce higher profits for the stock holder, but the primary job of any for profit company is not to produce widgets, automobiles, or sell health insurance... it is to make money for stock holders. For health insurance companies, that means denying coverage. If they can deny a procedure, they have made more money. It is no surprise then that for profit insurance companies have employees whose job is to find ways to deny coverage to the patients and they get bonuses when they do so. At least a panel of government agents making decisions around coverage would have the well being of the larger population as their primary concern.
The bottom line is that the current system, even under Obamacare, cannot solve the problems we face and will remain the most expensive health care delivery system in the world while at the same time being far down the list in terms of almost all of the significant metrics for outcomes. The good news is that there are models around the world that actually work. All we need do is swallow our pride and embrace a model that delivers health care to all of our citizens at a more reasonable price.
Thursday, June 28, 2012
Affordable Care Act
Today the SCOTUS ruled that Obamacare is constitutional. I am not a lawyer and don't claim to understand whether or not it is a good ruling. My gut says "yes," but that is an opinion without any real basis so take it with that degree of impact.
Whether or not the law is constitutional has nothing to do with whether or not it is a good law and there are those on the right and the left who are arguing that it is not a good law. Those on the right say that the law interferes with the movement of the free market and impacts the freedom of individuals. Those on the left argue that health insurance is too important to be subject to the whims of the free market and should never be a for-profit business and that this law will make the movement towards establishing a non-profit, single payer system more difficult to accomplish.
I hoped for at least the option of a single payer system all along and in the best of all worlds, that is what Obamacare would have been. I'm not sure how this law will impact that possibility. There are those who argue that the constraints on the private insurance companies included in this law will drive them out of the health insurance business and push us towards single payer. Others argue that this law just entrenches the for profit health insurance companies which will keep us from moving towards single payer. Time will tell.
The Republicans will vote to repeal this law although, it isn't clear that they would do this if they really had the power to make it happen. Being seen as responsible for removing the popular provisions of this law is not likely something they really would want and keeping the popular provisions without the individual mandate is not something the insurance companies are likely to be happy about...
Interesting times.
Whether or not the law is constitutional has nothing to do with whether or not it is a good law and there are those on the right and the left who are arguing that it is not a good law. Those on the right say that the law interferes with the movement of the free market and impacts the freedom of individuals. Those on the left argue that health insurance is too important to be subject to the whims of the free market and should never be a for-profit business and that this law will make the movement towards establishing a non-profit, single payer system more difficult to accomplish.
I hoped for at least the option of a single payer system all along and in the best of all worlds, that is what Obamacare would have been. I'm not sure how this law will impact that possibility. There are those who argue that the constraints on the private insurance companies included in this law will drive them out of the health insurance business and push us towards single payer. Others argue that this law just entrenches the for profit health insurance companies which will keep us from moving towards single payer. Time will tell.
The Republicans will vote to repeal this law although, it isn't clear that they would do this if they really had the power to make it happen. Being seen as responsible for removing the popular provisions of this law is not likely something they really would want and keeping the popular provisions without the individual mandate is not something the insurance companies are likely to be happy about...
Interesting times.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



