more on the saga of health insurance for our daughter, son-in-law, and grandson on the way...
One month before Christian lost his job, his employer switched health insurance providers. That is always a pain as you have to find out whether your providers are still covered and if not, find new ones... but that was more complicated for them. Neither insurance covered the birth center and midwives they were using for the pregnancy and birth. They had negotiated coverage with the first insurance company - Anthem Blue Cross. After all, midwives and birth centers are way cheaper than doctors and hospitals. It made fiscal sense for them but it was a hassle for Christian and Alexis. They were in process of trying to negotiate the coverage with the second provider when Christian was fired.
Fast forward a few weeks... Every time you do a web search on COBRA, an ad pops up for Anthem Blue Cross as a COBRA alternative. So Christian contacted them... and they told him they would not insure his family as pregnancy is a pre-existing condition. It didn't matter that they had been insured all along and until a month ago, their insurance was with Anthem Blue Cross... they are not eligible for insurance from them. Luckily, they do still have the option of COBRA. As I understand it, that continues with the provider they had when Christian lost his job so they begin negotiations again.
As I said in my previous post, the Affordable Care Act cannot kick in soon enough.
Showing posts with label Affordable Care Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Affordable Care Act. Show all posts
Tuesday, July 30, 2013
Wednesday, July 17, 2013
Health Insurance... the ACA can't come soon enough
Two weeks go my son-in-law lost his job. That is bad enough under the best of circumstances... but the circumstances are anything but "best." My daughter is 7 months pregnant. They have health insurance through the end of July... but the baby is due in September. They had decided to do their birth at a birth center with a midwife which involved negotiating with their insurance company to begin with... They live in one of the most expensive areas of the country . Of course, if they move, they have to find medical systems for the birth of the baby and find health insurance. If they stay, they have to figure out how to pay rent plus get health insurance. Christian got a job quickly although that income will render them ineligible for any government aid... and he is not eligible for health insurance at his new job for 90 days. Of course, he has not started as they wait for his drug test to return from the lab. And there is the ever there and overwhelming shadow of student loans which equal monthly payments higher than rent in most areas of the country. Those bills have made it impossible to accumulate any savings... so there is no money for COBRA or as a buffer against other costs. The ACA would make things easier for them... but it doesn't kick in completely until January.
My son has not had health insurance for over two years... and that makes us very nervous. He is an athlete and plays basketball, softball, and flag football at least twice a week. One injury and his life would be a mess. John rarely gets ill but when he does, he does. Since childhood he has run very high fevers. A year ago, he got some sort of virus and woke in the middle of the night with a fever of 104. You can imagine the fear and the number crunching that went on that night... does he got to the ER? The bills would be far beyond his ability to pay. Even to wait and go to Urgent Care in the morning would be devastating to his finances. He was able to get his temperature down and he went to Urgent Care the next morning. His income is minimal so he will be eligible for the MediCal part of the ACA beginning in January. It is not good insurance but it is something and I will breathe easier.
The same day Christian was fired, I received a note from MMBB, the benefits board for our denomination. As of January 2014, MMBB will no longer offer health insurance. Since moving to California we have gotten our health insurance through them. It is a reasonably good plan but is extremely expensive. Due to California insurance laws, the only other option for me would be to get insurance as an individual. Because of my familial hyperlipidemia no insurance company would offer me insurance at any price. Through the years, the MMBB medical plan became the plan of last resort for clergy in my denomination. Anyone who could get insurance elsewhere did. This led to an increasingly smaller and higher risk pool in a demographic group that is already higher risk than the general population (clergy tend to be older and have more stress and lifestyle related problems than the general population). That adds up to obscenely high premiums. My church pays health insurance premiums that are almost equal to my salary for my spouse and me. Our son is eligible to be included but the cost is so prohibitive that neither the church nor us can shoulder that additional cost. It is not an easy situation for the church but without this option, I would not have been able to accept the call to this church.
Because of the expense, I have been asked to search out other options every year for the past few years and each year have received the same answer from the broker - "not insurable at any price." It doesn't matter that we've known about the condition since 1987, it has been under control by medications, I've had no incidents, and every test shows that my coronary arteries are healthy. I assumed that this year, I would be asked to investigate the insurance exchange set up via the Affordable Care Act. I did not expect that there would be no option via MMBB. It does make sense that we go with the exchange. The price for roughly equivalent coverage looks to be at least 30% less than the church is currently paying and according to the ACA, they cannot deny me coverage because of my condition. Still, the letter felt like a punch in the stomach... and every headline that I see stating that groups are trying to completely derail the ACA literally reads like a death sentence for me. Without the medications I likely would have died within a year or so of my diagnosis in '87. Indeed, the meds were new enough that they were unsure whether they would really help someone with my condition. One cardiologist told me, "We're hopeful, but just in case, get your affairs in order." If I had to stop them now, it might take a couple of years... and then I would begin having heart attacks.
One might say, "you could continue the meds, you'd just have to pay for them." True... sort of. The meds require regular blood tests, require a physician to monitor them and prescribe them (our experience in CA is that the primary care physicians don't want to do this so I'd need to see a cardiologist), and none of those costs are inexpensive. At this point, they are still significantly less than what the church has been paying in premiums but one small incident... Add that my wife is likely going to need a hip replacement in the next year or two...
Others might ask why they should shoulder any of my medical risk or costs? That is a real question and comes down to how one feels about community responsibility or the fact that we've been paying health insurance premiums for these years, supporting costs for the health care of others (and salaries and profits for the health insurance industry).
All of this is just to rant about a system that is clearly broken, looks to get better in 2014 but still is not nearly what it needs to be, and which is frightening and frustrating for me.
My son has not had health insurance for over two years... and that makes us very nervous. He is an athlete and plays basketball, softball, and flag football at least twice a week. One injury and his life would be a mess. John rarely gets ill but when he does, he does. Since childhood he has run very high fevers. A year ago, he got some sort of virus and woke in the middle of the night with a fever of 104. You can imagine the fear and the number crunching that went on that night... does he got to the ER? The bills would be far beyond his ability to pay. Even to wait and go to Urgent Care in the morning would be devastating to his finances. He was able to get his temperature down and he went to Urgent Care the next morning. His income is minimal so he will be eligible for the MediCal part of the ACA beginning in January. It is not good insurance but it is something and I will breathe easier.
The same day Christian was fired, I received a note from MMBB, the benefits board for our denomination. As of January 2014, MMBB will no longer offer health insurance. Since moving to California we have gotten our health insurance through them. It is a reasonably good plan but is extremely expensive. Due to California insurance laws, the only other option for me would be to get insurance as an individual. Because of my familial hyperlipidemia no insurance company would offer me insurance at any price. Through the years, the MMBB medical plan became the plan of last resort for clergy in my denomination. Anyone who could get insurance elsewhere did. This led to an increasingly smaller and higher risk pool in a demographic group that is already higher risk than the general population (clergy tend to be older and have more stress and lifestyle related problems than the general population). That adds up to obscenely high premiums. My church pays health insurance premiums that are almost equal to my salary for my spouse and me. Our son is eligible to be included but the cost is so prohibitive that neither the church nor us can shoulder that additional cost. It is not an easy situation for the church but without this option, I would not have been able to accept the call to this church.
Because of the expense, I have been asked to search out other options every year for the past few years and each year have received the same answer from the broker - "not insurable at any price." It doesn't matter that we've known about the condition since 1987, it has been under control by medications, I've had no incidents, and every test shows that my coronary arteries are healthy. I assumed that this year, I would be asked to investigate the insurance exchange set up via the Affordable Care Act. I did not expect that there would be no option via MMBB. It does make sense that we go with the exchange. The price for roughly equivalent coverage looks to be at least 30% less than the church is currently paying and according to the ACA, they cannot deny me coverage because of my condition. Still, the letter felt like a punch in the stomach... and every headline that I see stating that groups are trying to completely derail the ACA literally reads like a death sentence for me. Without the medications I likely would have died within a year or so of my diagnosis in '87. Indeed, the meds were new enough that they were unsure whether they would really help someone with my condition. One cardiologist told me, "We're hopeful, but just in case, get your affairs in order." If I had to stop them now, it might take a couple of years... and then I would begin having heart attacks.
One might say, "you could continue the meds, you'd just have to pay for them." True... sort of. The meds require regular blood tests, require a physician to monitor them and prescribe them (our experience in CA is that the primary care physicians don't want to do this so I'd need to see a cardiologist), and none of those costs are inexpensive. At this point, they are still significantly less than what the church has been paying in premiums but one small incident... Add that my wife is likely going to need a hip replacement in the next year or two...
Others might ask why they should shoulder any of my medical risk or costs? That is a real question and comes down to how one feels about community responsibility or the fact that we've been paying health insurance premiums for these years, supporting costs for the health care of others (and salaries and profits for the health insurance industry).
All of this is just to rant about a system that is clearly broken, looks to get better in 2014 but still is not nearly what it needs to be, and which is frightening and frustrating for me.
Thursday, July 05, 2012
The Problem with the Insurance Argument
After the Supreme Court ruling, the question of health insurance has come back to the front with Democrats celebrating and Republicans vowing to repeal. Democrats should not be celebrating and while the Republicans might be able to repeal the Affordable Care Act but they have no solution worth real discussion.
First off, the free market does not and can not work with regards to health care. The consumer has no power to influence the market at all. You can't shop for the lowest cost when you've just had a heart attack. Add that there is often only one hospital nearby and the physician on duty is the physician on duty. Most of us also have no control over what, if any, insurance is available to us and even less over what is covered by that policy. Employers may shop for the lowest price on insurance but it is very seldom that they do so while comparing two identical products and the dissimilarities may not be obvious until the product is used and the patient discovers that a specific lab or physician is not covered by their insurance. And the coverage is constantly changing so a physician covered one year may not be the next year. Which services and providers are covered by a given policy rarely if ever have anything to do with quality of care. Market forces simply do not work when it comes to health care so if we rely on them to control costs or quality, we will only see failure.
Second, there are some things that should not be sold for profit. Health care is one. In a for profit business, the business always has a primary responsibility to make money for the stock holders. There is a legal responsibility to do that regardless of whether they are producing widgets, automobiles, or providing health insurance. The first responsibility is not to the client, it is to the stock holder. Obviously, in the free market, a better product is more likely to produce higher profits for the stock holder, but the primary job of any for profit company is not to produce widgets, automobiles, or sell health insurance... it is to make money for stock holders. For health insurance companies, that means denying coverage. If they can deny a procedure, they have made more money. It is no surprise then that for profit insurance companies have employees whose job is to find ways to deny coverage to the patients and they get bonuses when they do so. At least a panel of government agents making decisions around coverage would have the well being of the larger population as their primary concern.
The bottom line is that the current system, even under Obamacare, cannot solve the problems we face and will remain the most expensive health care delivery system in the world while at the same time being far down the list in terms of almost all of the significant metrics for outcomes. The good news is that there are models around the world that actually work. All we need do is swallow our pride and embrace a model that delivers health care to all of our citizens at a more reasonable price.
First off, the free market does not and can not work with regards to health care. The consumer has no power to influence the market at all. You can't shop for the lowest cost when you've just had a heart attack. Add that there is often only one hospital nearby and the physician on duty is the physician on duty. Most of us also have no control over what, if any, insurance is available to us and even less over what is covered by that policy. Employers may shop for the lowest price on insurance but it is very seldom that they do so while comparing two identical products and the dissimilarities may not be obvious until the product is used and the patient discovers that a specific lab or physician is not covered by their insurance. And the coverage is constantly changing so a physician covered one year may not be the next year. Which services and providers are covered by a given policy rarely if ever have anything to do with quality of care. Market forces simply do not work when it comes to health care so if we rely on them to control costs or quality, we will only see failure.
Second, there are some things that should not be sold for profit. Health care is one. In a for profit business, the business always has a primary responsibility to make money for the stock holders. There is a legal responsibility to do that regardless of whether they are producing widgets, automobiles, or providing health insurance. The first responsibility is not to the client, it is to the stock holder. Obviously, in the free market, a better product is more likely to produce higher profits for the stock holder, but the primary job of any for profit company is not to produce widgets, automobiles, or sell health insurance... it is to make money for stock holders. For health insurance companies, that means denying coverage. If they can deny a procedure, they have made more money. It is no surprise then that for profit insurance companies have employees whose job is to find ways to deny coverage to the patients and they get bonuses when they do so. At least a panel of government agents making decisions around coverage would have the well being of the larger population as their primary concern.
The bottom line is that the current system, even under Obamacare, cannot solve the problems we face and will remain the most expensive health care delivery system in the world while at the same time being far down the list in terms of almost all of the significant metrics for outcomes. The good news is that there are models around the world that actually work. All we need do is swallow our pride and embrace a model that delivers health care to all of our citizens at a more reasonable price.
Thursday, June 28, 2012
Affordable Care Act
Today the SCOTUS ruled that Obamacare is constitutional. I am not a lawyer and don't claim to understand whether or not it is a good ruling. My gut says "yes," but that is an opinion without any real basis so take it with that degree of impact.
Whether or not the law is constitutional has nothing to do with whether or not it is a good law and there are those on the right and the left who are arguing that it is not a good law. Those on the right say that the law interferes with the movement of the free market and impacts the freedom of individuals. Those on the left argue that health insurance is too important to be subject to the whims of the free market and should never be a for-profit business and that this law will make the movement towards establishing a non-profit, single payer system more difficult to accomplish.
I hoped for at least the option of a single payer system all along and in the best of all worlds, that is what Obamacare would have been. I'm not sure how this law will impact that possibility. There are those who argue that the constraints on the private insurance companies included in this law will drive them out of the health insurance business and push us towards single payer. Others argue that this law just entrenches the for profit health insurance companies which will keep us from moving towards single payer. Time will tell.
The Republicans will vote to repeal this law although, it isn't clear that they would do this if they really had the power to make it happen. Being seen as responsible for removing the popular provisions of this law is not likely something they really would want and keeping the popular provisions without the individual mandate is not something the insurance companies are likely to be happy about...
Interesting times.
Whether or not the law is constitutional has nothing to do with whether or not it is a good law and there are those on the right and the left who are arguing that it is not a good law. Those on the right say that the law interferes with the movement of the free market and impacts the freedom of individuals. Those on the left argue that health insurance is too important to be subject to the whims of the free market and should never be a for-profit business and that this law will make the movement towards establishing a non-profit, single payer system more difficult to accomplish.
I hoped for at least the option of a single payer system all along and in the best of all worlds, that is what Obamacare would have been. I'm not sure how this law will impact that possibility. There are those who argue that the constraints on the private insurance companies included in this law will drive them out of the health insurance business and push us towards single payer. Others argue that this law just entrenches the for profit health insurance companies which will keep us from moving towards single payer. Time will tell.
The Republicans will vote to repeal this law although, it isn't clear that they would do this if they really had the power to make it happen. Being seen as responsible for removing the popular provisions of this law is not likely something they really would want and keeping the popular provisions without the individual mandate is not something the insurance companies are likely to be happy about...
Interesting times.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



